The Strategy Library
Strategy No. 14

Safe Money Without the Annual Tax DragThe Fixed Annuity

A strategy for conservative money that is sitting in CDs, money markets, and short bonds and quietly losing ground to taxes every April: a fixed annuity credits a rate the insurer guarantees for a set period, defers income tax on that interest until it is withdrawn, and can later be turned into a predictable stream of retirement income.

Retirement IncomeTax‑Advantaged Growth
Last reviewed: October 2026
Who It's For

Pre‑retirees and retirees, usually in their mid‑50s to mid‑70s, holding meaningful "safe money" in taxable CDs, Treasuries, or money markets that they do not need to spend for several years.

Key Benefit

Principal protection backed by the insurer, a rate locked for a known period, and tax deferral on the interest, so the client decides when the income shows up on a return instead of the bank deciding every year.

Trigger Question

Does this client have money in taxable CDs or money markets that they keep rolling over, will not touch for at least three to five years, and pay tax on every year whether they spend the interest or not?

Watch first

Instructional video
Josh Sterling teaches this strategy
In this walkthrough, Josh teaches how a fixed annuity really earns and is taxed: the difference between a multi‑year guaranteed annuity and a traditional declared‑rate contract, why income‑first taxation on withdrawals matters, how surrender schedules and market value adjustments work, and how to compare a fixed annuity to a CD or Treasury ladder on an after‑tax basis rather than on headline rate.

The full picture

What it is

A fixed annuity is a contract with a life insurance company. The client deposits a lump sum (or a series of deposits), and the insurer credits interest at a rate it guarantees for a stated period. The most common version for this planning job is the multi‑year guaranteed annuity (MYGA): the rate is fixed for the full term, often three to ten years, much like a CD. A traditional declared‑rate fixed annuity guarantees a first‑year rate and then resets annually, subject to a contractual minimum. In both versions the account value does not move with the stock or bond market. The client is relying on the insurer's general account and its claims‑paying ability, not on a bank and not on FDIC insurance.

The planning value is less about the rate and more about when the tax arrives. Interest credited inside a non‑qualified annuity is not taxed as it is earned. There is no annual 1099 for interest that stays in the contract. A CD paying a similar rate generates taxable interest every year, even when the client simply rolls it over. For a client in a meaningful bracket, especially one whose interest income also nudges Medicare premium surcharges or the taxation of Social Security benefits, the difference between "taxed every year" and "taxed when I choose to withdraw" compounds over time.

That deferral is not a tax exemption. Gains are eventually taxed as ordinary income, never at capital gains rates. Withdrawals from a non‑qualified annuity are generally taxed gain first, so early withdrawals come out fully taxable until the gain is used up. Withdrawals before age 59½ can carry a 10% additional federal tax on the taxable portion unless an exception applies. And annuity gains do not receive a step‑up in basis at death: a beneficiary who inherits the contract inherits the deferred tax with it. The strategy works when the client wants deferral and control over timing, not when the goal is to pass appreciated value to heirs.

Finally, the money is not fully liquid. Most contracts allow a penalty‑free withdrawal each year (commonly around 10% of the value) and waive surrender charges at death and often for nursing‑home confinement or terminal illness. Beyond that, withdrawals in the early years carry a surrender charge that steps down over the term, and some contracts add a market value adjustment that can raise or lower the surrender value depending on interest rates at the time.

Who it's for

The ideal client is conservative by temperament and specific in need. They are usually in the five to fifteen years around retirement. They hold a block of money they think of as "safe," often accumulated in CDs or money markets, that is not their emergency reserve and is not earmarked for a purchase in the next few years. They are in a tax bracket where annual interest income is a real cost, and they value predictability over upside. Often they have already built the market‑exposed portion of their portfolio and want the stable portion to work harder without taking market risk.

It is not for money the client may need on short notice, for a client under 59½ who expects to draw on it soon, or for wealth whose main purpose is to pass to children with a basis step‑up. It is also not a replacement for an emergency fund. The fit is "money that should be safe, will sit for a defined period, and is currently being taxed for sitting."

When / why the problem actually shows up

The need shows up in recognizable moments. A CD ladder matures and the client asks where to roll it. A client sells a business interest or a property and parks the proceeds in a money market "until we figure it out," and a year later it is still there. A tax preparer notices a large Form 1099‑INT on a return for interest the client never spent. A pre‑retiree wants to build a bridge of guaranteed money to cover the years between retirement and claiming Social Security. Or a client nearing Medicare enrollment learns that investment income can push their premiums up through income‑related surcharges and wants more control over what shows up as income in a given year.

Underneath all of these is the same pattern: conservative money that is guaranteed in name but slowly eroding, because inflation and annual tax take a meaningful share of a modest rate. The client is not wrong to want safety. The structure holding that safety is simply less efficient than it could be.

How it's structured

The moving parts are simple, which is part of the appeal:

  1. The owner (usually the client, sometimes a revocable trust) purchases the contract and controls withdrawals.
  2. The annuitant is the person whose life the contract is measured on, usually the owner.
  3. The beneficiary receives the value at death, with the deferred gain taxable to them as ordinary income.
  4. The insurer guarantees principal and the declared rate for the term, backed by its general account and claims‑paying ability, with state guaranty association coverage as a backstop up to limits that vary by state.

The flow: the client deposits a lump sum; interest is credited and compounds tax‑deferred for the guarantee period; small penalty‑free withdrawals are available along the way. At the end of the term the client has choices. They can withdraw (paying ordinary income tax on the gain), move the value to a new annuity through a Section 1035 exchange to continue deferral, or convert the value into guaranteed income through annuitization or an income rider. Annuitized payments are taxed partly as return of principal and partly as income under an exclusion ratio, which can make the income stream more tax‑efficient than taking the gain out first.

Two design choices drive most of the outcome. First, match the term to the time horizon: a five‑year guarantee for money needed in year six, not a ten‑year contract for money that might be needed in year four. Second, ladder rather than lump: splitting the money across contracts with different terms gives the client liquidity at staggered dates and spreads interest‑rate risk, the same way a well‑built CD or Treasury ladder does.

Red flags — what to look for

These are the observable signals that a fixed annuity may genuinely fit, and that the client's conservative money may be working less efficiently than it could.

  • CDs that keep rolling over. The client mentions renewing CDs at the bank every year or two, with no plan to spend the money. Rolling over is the tell: the money is long‑term in practice but taxed as if it were short‑term.
  • A large Form 1099‑INT on the return. Five‑figure interest income the client did not need and did not spend, taxed at ordinary rates every year.
  • Proceeds parked in a money market "for now." Sale proceeds, an inheritance, or a bonus sitting in cash for a year or more because the client did not want market risk and no one offered a structured alternative.
  • A pre‑retiree planning a Social Security bridge. Someone who intends to delay claiming and needs a predictable source of money for the years in between, without exposing that money to a market decline right before retirement.
  • Income‑sensitive thresholds in view. A client close to the income levels where Medicare premium surcharges or the taxation of Social Security benefits change, who would benefit from controlling when interest is recognized.
  • A client who has said plainly, "I can't afford to lose this." Stated loss aversion on a specific block of money, combined with frustration at low after‑tax returns.
  • An old annuity sitting past its surrender period. An existing contract that renewed at a low floor rate years ago and is now earning far less than current guarantees, which may be a candidate for a Section 1035 exchange after a careful comparison.

Common pitfalls

  • Comparing headline rates instead of after‑tax results. A fixed annuity rate and a CD rate are not directly comparable. The annuity's advantage is deferral; its cost is ordinary‑income treatment at withdrawal and the loss of a basis step‑up at death. Model both on an after‑tax basis over the client's actual horizon, including how the money will eventually come out.
  • Locking up money the client may need. Surrender charges are real, and a market value adjustment can reduce the surrender value when rates have risen. Size the contract to money the client truly will not touch, and keep the emergency reserve separate.
  • Ignoring the gain‑first rule on withdrawals. Clients often assume early withdrawals are part principal and part interest. For a non‑qualified annuity, withdrawals generally come out as taxable gain first. A client who plans to draw income early should understand that the first dollars out are fully taxable, and that annuitization or a planned withdrawal schedule may be more efficient.
  • Using it for legacy money. If the real goal is to leave this money to children, deferred annuity gains pass to them as taxable income with no step‑up. Other tools may move the same dollars more efficiently.
  • Concentrating with one insurer. Guarantees are only as strong as the insurer, and state guaranty association limits are capped and vary by state. Evaluate financial strength ratings, and for large amounts consider splitting across carriers.
  • Buying past the guarantee period by default. At the end of the term many contracts renew at a new declared rate that may be lower than what the market offers. Put the maturity date on the calendar and decide deliberately rather than letting the contract drift.
  • A 1035 exchange that resets surrender charges for little benefit. Exchanges can be valuable, but replacing a contract only to restart a new surrender schedule for a marginal rate improvement does not serve the client. Every replacement deserves a documented side‑by‑side comparison.

Client example

This is a composite, illustrative example, not a specific client.

The client. A 62‑year‑old couple, both still working, planning to retire in three years and delay Social Security to 70. They had roughly $600,000 in CDs and a money market accumulated over two decades of conservative saving, alongside a diversified 401(k) and brokerage account. They paid ordinary income tax every year on CD interest they rolled straight back into new CDs, and they were adamant that this block of money was "not for the market."

The trigger. Their CPA flagged that their interest income had become one of the larger line items on their return, and that in retirement the same interest would stack on top of IRA withdrawals and could push them toward Medicare premium surcharge thresholds. At the same time, their financial planner was mapping the five years between retirement and claiming Social Security and needed a predictable source of money for that bridge. The question became whether the safe money could be structured to fund that bridge more efficiently.

The structure. The planner, the CPA, and the strategist built a fixed annuity ladder for about $400,000 of the safe money, leaving the rest in cash and short Treasuries as the true reserve. The ladder used multi‑year guaranteed annuities with staggered terms so contracts would mature in the years the couple expected to need money, each from a highly rated insurer, with no single carrier holding more than the state guaranty limit the team was comfortable with. Interest would compound tax‑deferred until each maturity. At each maturity the couple would decide, with their CPA, whether to withdraw the gain in a lower‑income year, annuitize a portion for steady income, or exchange into a new contract.

The outcome. The structure is designed to remove annual interest from their return during their highest‑earning remaining years and let them recognize it later, when they choose and when their bracket may be lower. The bridge years before Social Security are covered by money with no market exposure. Their principal is protected by the insurers' guarantees within the limits discussed. And they understand the trade‑offs clearly: the gain will be taxed as ordinary income when withdrawn, the money is committed for each term, and this block is meant to be spent in retirement rather than left to heirs. Results will depend on the rates available at purchase and on the timing of their withdrawals.

The advisor angle

Fixed annuities rarely come up in planning conversations, partly because the strategy looks unexciting and partly because annuities as a category carry baggage. That is exactly why the conservative portion of a client's balance sheet often goes unexamined. The money in CDs is "handled," so it does not get the same scrutiny as the portfolio. Asking how that money is taxed, and when it will actually be spent, often surfaces a better structure.

The useful skill here is being precise about trade‑offs. A fixed annuity is not a CD with a better rate; it is a different tax and liquidity profile. The planner who can explain the gain‑first rule, the lack of a basis step‑up, surrender schedules, and insurer risk with the same clarity as the deferral benefit earns trust that a rate quote never will. It also connects naturally to the larger conversations around retirement income sequencing, Medicare thresholds, and Social Security timing, where the CPA, the planner, and the strategist each hold a piece. Bringing those pieces together around one block of money is what turns a rollover decision into planning.

Let's talk

Have a client who may benefit?

Bring the situation — we'll pressure‑test the fit and the structure together. New to working with Josh? Start with an Introduction.

To be clear, this isn't a product pitch. Sometimes the right answer for safe money is a Treasury ladder, and I'll say so. If a fixed annuity fits, we'll build it together. If it doesn't, you'll walk away sharper.