The Strategy Library
Strategy No. 15

An Income Floor Under Market MoneyVariable Annuities with Living Benefits

A strategy for retirees who need their portfolio to stay invested for growth but cannot afford for a bad market early in retirement to cut their income for life: a variable annuity with a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit keeps the money in market subaccounts while the insurer contractually guarantees a minimum income stream, even if the account value is later depleted.

Retirement Income
Last reviewed: October 2026
Who It's For

Pre‑retirees and new retirees, typically 55 to 70, who will rely on their portfolio for a meaningful share of income, want to stay invested, and are anxious about a market decline in the first years of retirement.

Key Benefit

A contractual lifetime income floor on a defined portion of the portfolio, with continued market participation and tax deferral, which can let the rest of the portfolio be invested with more confidence.

Trigger Question

If the market fell sharply in this client's first two years of retirement, would they have to cut their lifestyle permanently, and do they have a source of income they cannot outlive beyond Social Security?

Watch first

Instructional video
Josh Sterling teaches this strategy
In this walkthrough, Josh teaches how a living‑benefit rider actually works: the difference between the income base and the real account value, how roll‑ups and step‑ups are calculated, why the withdrawal percentage is locked by age, what the layered fees cost, how excess withdrawals can shrink the guarantee, and what these contracts can and cannot do for long‑term care.

The full picture

What it is

A variable annuity is an insurance contract whose value is invested in subaccounts, which work much like mutual funds. The account value rises and falls with those investments, and growth is tax‑deferred until withdrawn. On its own, that is simply a tax‑deferred investment wrapper with insurance costs attached. The planning value comes from an optional living‑benefit rider, most commonly a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit (GLWB).

The GLWB creates a second number alongside the account value: the income base (sometimes called the benefit base). The income base is not money the client can withdraw as a lump sum. It is a calculation value used only to determine guaranteed income. It typically starts at the initial deposit, may grow by a contractual roll‑up percentage during a waiting period, and may step up to lock in market gains on anniversary dates. When the client begins income, the insurer applies a withdrawal percentage, set by the client's age at first withdrawal, to the income base. That annual amount is guaranteed for life (single or joint), even if the account value later falls to zero through withdrawals, fees, and poor markets. If the investments perform well, the client keeps the upside in the account value and may see the income base step up further.

The core problem it solves is sequence‑of‑returns risk. Two retirees with the same average return can have very different outcomes depending on when the losses arrive. Losses in the first years of withdrawals do disproportionate damage, because the client is selling assets at low prices to fund income. A GLWB transfers that particular risk to the insurer for the covered portion of the portfolio.

On long‑term care: some contracts offer an income enhancement that increases the guaranteed withdrawal, sometimes doubling it for a period, if the client cannot perform a set number of activities of daily living or is confined to a care facility. That can help, but it is not long‑term care insurance. It raises income from the same contract; it does not create a pool of care benefits the way a hybrid life and long‑term care policy does. Where care funding is the primary goal, that is a different strategy (see Strategy #17).

Who it's for

The ideal client is approaching or entering retirement with a portfolio that must produce a meaningful share of their spending, beyond what Social Security and any pension cover. They want to remain invested because they understand that a 25- or 30‑year retirement needs growth, but they are uneasy about a downturn early on. Often they have no pension and feel the absence of a "paycheck" in retirement. They are willing to accept higher ongoing costs in exchange for a guarantee on a portion of their money, and they are disciplined enough to take withdrawals within the contract's limits. Married couples who want income to continue for the surviving spouse are a natural fit for joint‑life versions.

It is a poor fit for a client who wants maximum growth and can absorb volatility, a client who will need large or irregular withdrawals, a client whose income needs are already covered by guaranteed sources, or someone who is highly fee‑sensitive and would be better served by a simpler income annuity.

When / why the problem actually shows up

The need surfaces at clear moments. A client retires from an employer and rolls a 401(k) into an IRA, and for the first time the portfolio has to replace a paycheck. A couple looks at a retirement projection that works under average returns but fails under a bad first few years. A client who lived through a sharp market decline near a previous milestone says they cannot do it again. A widow or widower who now manages the household's money alone wants a guaranteed floor. Or a client with no pension notices that friends with pensions seem calmer about the market than they are.

The pattern is a client who needs both growth and certainty from the same pool of money and has only been offered one or the other. The rider is designed to give a defined portion of that pool both, at a known cost.

How it's structured

  1. The owner buys the contract (inside an IRA through a rollover, or with non‑qualified money) and chooses the subaccounts, usually within allocation limits the insurer imposes when a living benefit is attached.
  2. The insurer holds the subaccounts in a separate account, deducts contract charges (mortality and expense, administrative, subaccount expenses) plus the rider fee, and backs the lifetime income guarantee with its own claims‑paying ability.
  3. The covered lives are the client alone or the client and spouse; joint coverage usually means a lower withdrawal percentage in exchange for income that lasts for both lifetimes.

The flow: the client deposits money, which is invested in subaccounts. During an optional deferral period the income base may roll up or step up. At income start, the age‑based withdrawal percentage is applied to the income base to set the guaranteed annual amount. Each year the client withdraws up to that amount, which reduces the account value but does not reduce the guarantee. Withdrawals above the guaranteed amount are "excess" and can reduce the income base proportionally, sometimes sharply. If the account value is ever exhausted, the insurer continues paying the guaranteed amount for life. At death, any remaining account value (or a death benefit, if one was elected) passes to beneficiaries.

Taxation follows annuity rules. Inside an IRA, withdrawals are ordinary income just like any other IRA distribution, and they count toward required minimum distributions. Outside an IRA, gains come out first as ordinary income, there is no step‑up in basis at death, and withdrawals before 59½ can carry a 10% additional tax. Variable annuities are securities as well as insurance contracts, so they come with a prospectus and suitability obligations specific to deferred variable annuities.

Red flags — what to look for

  • A retirement plan that only works on average returns. The projection succeeds at a steady assumed return but fails under a poor sequence early on. That fragility is exactly what the rider addresses.
  • No pension and a portfolio expected to replace a paycheck. The client's guaranteed income is Social Security alone, and the portfolio must carry the rest.
  • A client who sold near a previous bottom. History of panic selling in a downturn suggests that a guaranteed floor may keep them invested in the rest of the portfolio.
  • A large 401(k) rollover at retirement. A single, sizable decision point where part of the money can be structured for guaranteed income while the rest remains fully flexible.
  • A married couple worried about the survivor. One spouse manages the money and worries about the other managing it alone after their death.
  • An existing variable annuity with an old rider. A contract bought years ago whose income base, fees, and withdrawal terms have never been reviewed. Older riders can be valuable and worth keeping, or expensive and worth reconsidering; either way they deserve a read.
  • A client asking whether an annuity covers long‑term care. That question deserves a careful answer, because most variable annuity income enhancements are far narrower than true care coverage.

Common pitfalls

  • Treating the income base as real money. The most common misunderstanding. Clients see an income base growing at a roll‑up rate and believe their money is growing at that rate. It is not. The income base sets income; only the account value can be withdrawn or left to heirs.
  • Underestimating total cost. Contract charges, subaccount expenses, and the rider fee add up and are deducted from the account value every year. Total costs on these contracts are meaningfully higher than a typical portfolio. That cost is the price of the guarantee and should be weighed against what the guarantee is worth for this client.
  • Breaking the guarantee with excess withdrawals. One large unplanned withdrawal can reduce the income base far more than the dollar amount taken. Build a separate liquid reserve so the contract is never the emergency fund.
  • Putting too much of the portfolio in it. The rider is a tool for a defined slice of the portfolio, sized to the income floor the client needs. Committing everything sacrifices liquidity and adds cost to money that does not need the guarantee.
  • Starting income at the wrong age. Withdrawal percentages step up with age at first withdrawal. Starting early locks in a lower percentage for life; waiting too long forfeits years of income. Model the start date against the rest of the retirement income plan, including Social Security timing.
  • Overselling the long‑term care feature. An income enhancement during confinement is not a care plan. Present it accurately and, where care is the real concern, address it with a dedicated strategy.
  • Replacing an older contract without a careful comparison. Older living‑benefit riders sometimes carry more generous terms than anything available today. A replacement needs a documented, line‑by‑line comparison of what is given up and what is gained, including any new surrender schedule.

Client example

This is a composite, illustrative example, not a specific client.

The client. A married couple, both 63, retiring within a year. Neither had a pension. Their combined Social Security would cover roughly half of their planned spending, and their $1.6M of retirement savings, mostly in 401(k)s, would need to cover the rest for what could be thirty years. Their planner's projection worked comfortably at average returns, but stress tests with a severe decline in the first two years showed them having to cut spending deeply in their late 70s.

The trigger. In the review meeting, one spouse said directly that they had moved to cash during a previous decline and regretted it, and that they did not trust themselves to stay invested if it happened again right after retirement. The planner recognized that the portfolio allocation was not the weak link. The couple's behavior under stress was, and a guaranteed floor might be what let them stay invested in the rest of the portfolio.

The structure. The planner and the strategist sized an income floor: the amount, beyond Social Security, needed to cover essential expenses. About $500,000 of the rollover went into a variable annuity with a joint‑life GLWB, with subaccounts in a balanced allocation within the insurer's limits. The couple planned to begin withdrawals at 65 to capture a higher age‑based percentage, using cash reserves for the two‑year bridge. The remaining $1.1M stayed in a conventional portfolio, now able to be invested for long‑term growth because essential spending was covered by guaranteed sources. A separate cash reserve was set up so they would never need an excess withdrawal from the annuity.

The outcome. The design gives the couple a guaranteed lifetime income amount from the annuity that, together with Social Security, covers their essential expenses for as long as either of them lives, regardless of market performance, subject to the insurer's claims‑paying ability. If markets do well, the account value and possibly the income base can grow. If markets do poorly early on, essential spending is protected and the rest of the portfolio has time to recover. They understand the costs, the withdrawal discipline the contract requires, and that this annuity is an income tool, not a care plan; long‑term care was addressed separately.

The advisor angle

Variable annuities are one of the most polarizing tools in planning, and much of that reputation was earned by contracts that were sold rather than designed. The useful position is neither enthusiasm nor reflexive rejection. It is precision: knowing what a living benefit guarantees, what it costs, and the narrow set of clients for whom that trade is worth making.

When the guarantee is sized to an essential‑expense floor and paired with a liquid reserve, it can change how a client behaves in a downturn, which is often worth more than the guarantee itself. Getting there involves the rollover, Social Security timing, tax sequencing of withdrawals, and the long‑term care question, which typically sit with different professionals. Laying out the trade‑offs in plain language, including the cost and the limits of any care feature, gives the client a clear basis for deciding, whatever they decide.

Let's talk

Have a client who may benefit?

Bring the situation — we'll pressure‑test the fit and the structure together. New to working with Josh? Start with an Introduction.

To be clear, this isn't a product pitch. Many clients are better served without a variable annuity, and I'll tell you when that's the answer. If it fits, we'll design it together. If it doesn't, you'll walk away sharper.