The Strategy Library
Strategy No. 37

Private Credit LockupsCash Value as a Liquid Complement

Clients drawn to private credit for its steady income often accept multi‑year lockups, limited redemption rights, and fully taxable interest, which can leave them without liquidity when they need it most. Cash value in a permanent life insurance policy can serve as a different kind of fixed‑income‑like holding: designed for tax‑deferred growth, accessible through policy loans, and backed by an insurer's general account. It is a complement to a private credit allocation, not a replacement for it.

Tax‑Advantaged Growth
Last reviewed: October 2026
Who It's For

High‑net‑worth investors who hold or are considering private credit funds or other illiquid income strategies, have a long horizon, and value liquidity and tax efficiency in the conservative part of their balance sheet.

Key Benefit

A conservative, tax‑deferred holding the client can borrow against on their own schedule without selling or waiting for a redemption window, plus a death benefit, alongside whatever income allocation the client's investment advisor recommends.

Trigger Question

If this client needed cash during the next credit downturn, how much of their income allocation could they actually reach, how fast, and what would it cost them in tax?

Watch first

Instructional video
Josh Sterling teaches this strategy
In this walkthrough, Josh teaches what a policy's cash value has in common with private credit and where the comparison breaks down: how an insurer's general account is invested, why crediting and dividends are not guaranteed returns, how a policy loan gives the owner collateralized access without a redemption queue, how funding pace protects the tax treatment, and why this belongs beside an investment advisor's allocation rather than in place of it.

The full picture

What it is

Private credit (direct lending to companies, asset‑based loans, and similar strategies held through funds) has become a common allocation for wealthy investors. Its appeal is real: contractual income, collateral, and returns that do not move with public markets day to day. Its tradeoffs are real too. Many vehicles lock up capital for years or allow redemptions only quarterly and subject to limits that can be reduced in stressed markets. The interest it pays is generally taxed as ordinary income each year. And an investor who needs cash during a credit downturn may find that the part of their portfolio they thought of as stable is the part they cannot reach.

The comparison with life insurance cash value starts with how insurers invest. A life insurer's general account, which backs the guarantees and crediting of whole life and many universal life policies, is invested primarily in bonds and loans. Industry data from S&P Global Market Intelligence show that privately placed bonds have grown to close to half of the life industry's bond holdings. In that sense a policyowner already has indirect exposure to the same broad category of lending, held inside a regulated, diversified, long‑duration portfolio, with the insurer rather than the client bearing the investment management and the client receiving guaranteed values plus non‑guaranteed dividends or crediting.

The differences are what make it useful. Cash value is designed to grow tax‑deferred, with no annual tax on credited interest or dividends. The owner can borrow against it through a policy loan at any time after values develop, without a credit application, a redemption window, or selling anything; the loan is generally not taxable while the policy is in force and is not a modified endowment contract. The value does not fall when credit markets reprice. And the policy carries a death benefit. What it does not offer is a high yield: early surrender values are typically below premiums paid, long‑run growth depends on the insurer's general account performance and costs, and dividends and crediting are not guaranteed. The honest framing is a conservative, liquid, tax‑efficient holding that can sit beside private credit, not a substitute for its income.

Who it's for

The best‑fit client is an accredited, high‑net‑worth investor with a meaningful allocation to private credit or other illiquid income strategies, or one who is being offered such an allocation. They are in a high income tax bracket, which makes the annual tax on fund income a significant drag. They have a long horizon (ten years or more) for at least part of their conservative money, are insurable, and would value having liquidity they control during a market stress. Often they are real estate investors, business owners, or families with recurring capital needs who want a source of cash that does not depend on a fund manager's redemption decisions. Clients who need all of their conservative money accessible at full value next year, or who are seeking maximum income, are not the right fit.

When / why the problem actually shows up

The issue appears at specific points. A client is presented with a private credit fund and asks how it compares with what they already own. A redemption request on an interval or evergreen fund is limited or delayed during a period of market stress. A client's tax return shows a large amount of ordinary income from credit funds that they never spend and simply reinvest. A real estate investor or business owner with recurring capital calls realizes that their stable assets are the hardest ones to reach on short notice. Or an estate plan calls for liquidity at death and the family is considering coverage separately from its investment decisions. In each of these, the client is relying on one category of holding to be both income‑producing and available, and it may not be both at once.

How it's structured

The structure is designed around access and tax treatment rather than yield:

  1. The owner is the client or, when estate planning is part of the purpose, an irrevocable trust so the death benefit stays outside the taxable estate.
  2. The policy is designed for cash value rather than death benefit, commonly a whole life policy from a highly rated mutual or stock insurer with paid‑up additions, or a low‑load universal life design, with minimal death benefit for the premium.
  3. The funding is spread over enough years to stay within the seven‑pay limit, so the policy does not become a modified endowment contract and loans keep their favorable treatment.
  4. The coordination is with the client's investment advisor, who continues to manage the investment allocation, including any private credit. The policy sits on the balance sheet as a separate, conservative, liquid holding.

The flow: the client funds the policy over several years, and the cash value develops tax‑deferred. Once values have built, the client can borrow against the policy when a need or opportunity arises (a capital call, a property purchase, a period when a fund's redemptions are limited) and repay the loan on their own schedule. Under many designs the full cash value continues to be credited while a loan is outstanding. Any loan remaining at death is repaid from the death benefit, and the balance passes to beneficiaries generally free of income tax. The investment allocation is unchanged; the client simply has a source of liquidity that does not depend on it.

Red flags — what to look for

These are the observable signals that a client's income allocation is asked to provide both yield and liquidity, and may not deliver both.

  • A large private credit or interval fund allocation in a high tax bracket. Ordinary income taxed every year reduces the net benefit, especially when the income is reinvested rather than spent.
  • Experience with a limited or delayed redemption. A client who has been gated, or who has read about redemption limits in funds they own, understands the liquidity risk firsthand.
  • Recurring capital needs. Real estate investors and business owners with capital calls or acquisition plans need cash on their own timetable.
  • Conservative money held for ten years or more. Long‑horizon conservative dollars are the part of the balance sheet where a policy's early costs can be absorbed.
  • An estate plan that needs liquidity. If the family needs a death benefit anyway, building it for cash value can serve two purposes.
  • A client who asks how private credit compares with what they already own. That question opens a balanced conversation about liquidity and taxes, not just yield.
  • Good insurability. Lower insurance costs make the cash value design more efficient.

Common pitfalls

  • Selling it as a yield substitute. The policy is not designed to match private credit income, and no return should be promised or implied. Its value is in liquidity, tax treatment, and the death benefit, alongside the client's investments.
  • Ignoring early‑year values. Surrender values in the first years are typically below premiums paid. Money that may be needed soon belongs elsewhere.
  • Funding too fast. A large single deposit can create a modified endowment contract, making loans and withdrawals taxable to the extent of gain, with a possible 10 percent additional tax before age 59½.
  • Unmanaged loans. Loan interest compounds. Over‑borrowing can lead to lapse, and a lapse with a large loan outstanding can create taxable income.
  • Overlooking the insurer. The policy's guarantees depend on the insurer's claims‑paying ability. Carrier strength, dividend history, and general account quality deserve the same scrutiny an advisor would give a fund manager.
  • Working around the investment advisor. This is a balance sheet decision that should be made with the client's investment advisor, not as a reallocation behind their back. The advisor's allocation stays theirs.
  • Calling it private credit. The comparison is a teaching device. A policy is life insurance, regulated as such, and should never be described as a credit fund or an investment in one.

Client example

The client. An illustrative composite: a 55‑year‑old owner of a commercial real estate portfolio with steady cash flow and a top marginal tax rate. On his investment advisor's recommendation, he held a meaningful allocation to two private credit funds, which he valued for their income. He also faced recurring capital needs for property improvements and acquisitions, which he met from cash or by drawing on a credit line.

The trigger. During a period of market stress, one of his funds limited quarterly redemptions, and a property acquisition he wanted to pursue required cash on short notice. His CPA, reviewing his return, noted that most of the fund income had been reinvested rather than spent, while being taxed at ordinary rates. His investment advisor asked whether part of his long‑term conservative money could be held somewhere he could reach on his own schedule.

The structure. With his investment advisor's agreement, he kept his private credit allocation and redirected a portion of his annual surplus cash flow, money he did not expect to need for at least a decade, into a whole life policy designed for early cash value with paid‑up additions, funded over seven years within the seven‑pay limit. The policy was owned by an irrevocable trust aligned with his estate plan, with a trustee policy permitting loans for property needs. It was illustrated at guaranteed values as well as the current dividend scale, and no return comparison with his funds was made.

The outcome. After the early years, he had a conservative holding he could borrow against without waiting on a fund, applying for credit, or selling property, and its growth was not taxed each year. His private credit allocation stayed in place and continued to do its job. The trust gained a death benefit for estate liquidity. His investment advisor kept full responsibility for the portfolio, and his balance sheet now had a source of liquidity that did not depend on any manager's redemption decisions.

The advisor angle

Private credit decisions are made on yield, credit quality, and diversification, which is exactly where investment advisors should focus. What can be harder to see from inside the allocation is how the client's whole balance sheet behaves when liquidity tightens, and how much of their income is taxed every year without ever being spent.

A balanced way to raise it: "If your redemptions were limited for a year, where would you get cash, and what is your income allocation costing you in tax?" That keeps your allocation intact and adds a separate, conservative, liquid layer beside it. You don't need to change the portfolio or evaluate policies yourself. You need to recognize when a client's stable money and accessible money are not the same money, and bring in the strategist to design a complement with you.

Let's talk

Have a client who may benefit?

Bring the situation — we'll pressure‑test the fit and the structure together. New to working with Josh? Start with an Introduction.

And to be clear, this isn't a product pitch, and it isn't investment advice. The allocation stays with you. If a liquid complement fits, we'll build it together. If it's not, you'll walk away sharper.