The Strategy Library
Strategy No. 43

Equity Compensation RiskRSUs and Stock Options

A planning approach for executives whose net worth is concentrated in employer stock and unvested awards: the plan addresses what the family loses if the executive dies before awards vest, how the estate pays tax on a concentrated position it may not want to sell, and where the proceeds of a disciplined diversification plan should go, with permanent life insurance as one of the tools that holds the plan together.

Executive BenefitsEstate & Wealth Transfer
Last reviewed: October 2026
Who It's For

Executives and senior employees with significant restricted stock units, stock options, or performance shares, whose household balance sheet leans heavily on one company's stock and on awards that have not yet vested.

Key Benefit

Protects the family against forfeited awards and a forced sale at a bad moment, provides estate liquidity for a concentrated position, and gives diversification proceeds a tax‑advantaged, uncorrelated destination.

Trigger Question

If this executive died this year, how much of the wealth the family is counting on would actually reach them, and would the estate have to sell the stock to pay what it owes?

Watch first

Instructional video
Josh Sterling teaches this strategy
In this walkthrough, Josh teaches how equity compensation actually behaves at death and at tax time: why unvested awards often vanish, how withholding on vesting RSUs can fall short for high earners, how option exercise windows close after death, and where life insurance fits honestly in the plan, and where it does not.

The full picture

What it is

Equity compensation creates real wealth and real fragility at the same time. An executive may have a seven- or eight‑figure net worth on paper, but much of it is one company's stock, some of it has not vested, some of it is options that are only worth something above a strike price, and all of it moves with a single share price. The household plan often treats that number as if it were cash.

Three problems hide inside that number.

The forfeiture problem. Unvested restricted stock units and options are governed by the company's plan documents. Many plans forfeit unvested awards at death; some accelerate vesting in full or in part; some depend on a performance condition that may never be measured. Vested options typically must be exercised within a limited post‑death window set by the plan. A family plan that counts unvested awards as part of the estate may be counting money that will never arrive.

The tax and timing problem. RSUs are taxed as ordinary income when they vest. Nonqualified stock options are taxed as ordinary income on the spread when exercised. Incentive stock options can trigger alternative minimum tax at exercise and require holding periods for favorable treatment. Employers commonly withhold federal tax on these supplemental wages at a flat 22%, rising to 37% only on supplemental wages above $1 million in a year. An executive in a higher bracket, especially in a high‑tax state, can owe far more than was withheld, and the bill arrives whether or not the stock has held its value.

The concentration problem. A large single‑stock position, often subject to trading windows, blackout periods, and ownership guidelines, is hard to diversify quickly. If the executive dies, the estate inherits that concentration, may owe estate tax measured against it, and may need to sell into whatever the market is doing to pay that tax.

Life insurance is not the answer to all three, and good planning says so. It does not solve under‑withholding at vesting; that is a tax planning and cash flow question. It does not replace diversification. What it can do is specific: replace the value of awards that would be forfeited at death, provide liquidity so an estate is not forced to sell a concentrated position at the wrong time, and serve as a disciplined, tax‑advantaged destination for part of the proceeds as the executive diversifies over time.

Who it's for

The ideal client is an executive or senior employee, often in their 40s or 50s, with a meaningful and growing share of net worth in employer equity: annual RSU grants on multi‑year vesting schedules, option grants at various strike prices, or performance shares. They are typically high earners whose group life coverage at work is capped at a multiple of salary that ignores equity entirely, and that coverage ends when employment ends. Many are on track to accumulate an estate that will matter for federal purposes over time, or already face state estate tax exposure. Founders and early employees of pre‑IPO companies fit too, with extra complexity around valuation and liquidity.

When / why the problem actually shows up

The triggers are often tied to the compensation calendar. A large annual refresh grant lands and the household's projected net worth jumps on paper. A tax return reveals a large balance due because withholding on vested RSUs fell short. A company stock run‑up makes the position a much larger share of the family's wealth than anyone intended. An executive is promoted to an officer role and becomes subject to tighter trading restrictions. A spouse asks what happens to "the stock" if something happens. A divorce or estate plan update requires listing every award, and the plan documents reveal what happens at death. Each of these is a natural moment to separate the equity the family can count on from the equity it is merely hoping for.

How it's structured

  1. Inventory the equity. List every grant: type, vesting dates, strike prices, performance conditions, and, critically, what the plan document says happens at death, disability, and termination. This step alone often changes the plan.
  2. Separate vested from at‑risk value. Vested shares and in‑the‑money vested options are real (subject to market risk). Unvested awards that forfeit at death are not part of the family's protected wealth.
  3. Size coverage to the at‑risk value and the estate's liquidity need. A permanent or long‑duration policy, usually owned by an irrevocable life insurance trust (ILIT) so the proceeds sit outside the taxable estate, sized to replace forfeitable value and to provide liquidity for estate tax on the concentrated position.
  4. Coordinate with a diversification plan. Where the executive can sell, often through a pre‑arranged trading plan adopted during an open window, a portion of after‑tax sale proceeds can fund premiums through annual gifts to the ILIT, steadily moving wealth from a single correlated asset into an uncorrelated, tax‑advantaged one.
  5. Address the tax side separately. Estimated payments or elected additional withholding for vesting RSUs, an AMT analysis before exercising incentive stock options, and timing of exercises across tax years belong to the CPA and the executive's tax plan.

The parties are the executive (insured and grantor), the ILIT and its independent trustee (owner and beneficiary of the policy), the family (trust beneficiaries), the carrier, and the executive's tax advisor, who keeps the compensation‑side tax plan aligned.

Red flags — what to look for

These are the observable signals in a real client situation that this planning may fit.

  • A net worth statement that counts unvested awards at full value. If the family's plan assumes those awards will be there, ask what the plan document says at death.
  • Group life at work as the only coverage. Employer coverage is usually capped at a multiple of base salary, excludes equity value, and ends when employment ends.
  • A large balance due on last year's return tied to RSU vesting. That is the under‑withholding signal, and a sign no one is coordinating the compensation calendar with the tax plan.
  • One company's stock making up a large share of investable wealth. Concentration, whether by choice, by trading restriction, or by inertia, is the core exposure.
  • Officer or director status. Trading windows, blackout periods, and holding requirements make it harder to diversify quickly, which raises the value of liquidity planning.
  • Out‑of‑the‑money or near‑the‑money options the family counts as wealth. Those can be worth nothing at the moment they are needed.
  • A spouse who does not know how the awards work. If the surviving spouse would have to manage exercise windows and tax elections under stress, the plan needs simplifying now.

Common pitfalls

  • Positioning insurance as a tax solution for vesting. It is not. A death benefit does not pay this year's tax on vested RSUs, and early‑year cash value is not a source of tax money. Keep the tax plan and the protection plan distinct.
  • Selling concentrated stock at a large tax cost just to fund premiums. Premium funding should flow from the diversification the client was going to do anyway, or from cash flow, not drive an unplanned sale.
  • Ignoring the plan documents. Assumptions about acceleration at death are often wrong in both directions. Read the award agreements.
  • Sizing coverage once and never revisiting it. New grants vest every year and the share price moves. The at‑risk value changes annually; review coverage on the same calendar as the equity.
  • Personal ownership of a large policy. For an executive whose estate is growing toward or past the exemption, or with state estate tax exposure, a personally owned death benefit adds to the estate it is meant to protect. An ILIT owned from inception avoids that.
  • Missing the post‑death exercise window. A surviving spouse or executor who does not know the deadline can let valuable vested options expire. Document the deadlines and who will act.
  • Treating ISO exercises casually. An incentive stock option exercise can create an alternative minimum tax bill on gains that disappear if the stock falls before sale. That belongs in a tax analysis before any exercise.

Client example

The client. A 47‑year‑old executive vice president at a publicly traded technology company, married with three children. Household net worth of roughly $11M on paper: $3M in vested company shares, $2.5M in unvested RSUs vesting over four years, $1.5M of vested options at various strike prices, and about $4M in retirement accounts, home equity, and a diversified portfolio. Group life at work: twice base salary, about $900,000. His spouse handled the family finances but had never read an award agreement.

The trigger. During tax preparation, his CPA found a large balance due, driven by RSUs that vested during the year with federal withholding at the flat supplemental rate while his marginal federal rate was far higher. The CPA used the moment to pull the award agreements. They showed that unvested RSUs would be forfeited at death, and that vested options had to be exercised within twelve months of death under his company's plan. Roughly $2.5M of the family's projected wealth would simply vanish if he died, and the surviving spouse would face exercise decisions, a concentrated position, and a tax bill all in the same year.

The structure. The CPA set up quarterly estimated payments and an AMT review before any incentive option exercise, closing the tax side of the problem. We established an ILIT with an independent trustee, and the trust acquired a $4M permanent policy, sized to replace the forfeitable RSU value and provide liquidity so the estate would not need to sell company stock in a down market. The executive adopted a pre‑arranged trading plan during an open window to sell a set number of shares each quarter. A portion of the after‑tax proceeds funds annual gifts to the ILIT, with Crummey notices to the children each year. The rest is directed to the diversified portfolio. We set a review each year after the annual grant cycle to resize coverage as new awards are granted and old ones vest.

The outcome. If the executive dies before his awards vest, his family is positioned to receive the protection those awards were supposed to provide, outside the estate and free of income tax, and the estate has liquidity to manage the concentrated position on its own timeline. His concentration falls steadily each quarter under a plan he does not have to time. His spouse now has a one‑page summary of every award, every deadline, and every person to call. The CPA who turned an unpleasant tax bill into a full review of the family's equity became the advisor the executive calls before every grant decision.

The advisor angle

Equity compensation is one of the places where a household's paper wealth and its real wealth can diverge sharply, and the difference rarely shows up until a tax bill or a death forces it. The questions that surface it are concrete: What does the plan document say happens to unvested awards at death? What was withheld when the RSUs vested, and what was actually owed? How much of the family's investable wealth is one stock?

The deeper value is in connecting pieces that usually sit with different people. The company's stock plan administrator manages the awards, the CPA sees the tax consequences after the fact, the investment advisor may not hold the concentrated shares at all, and the estate plan was drafted before most of the grants existed. Seeing the whole picture is where planning starts. You do not need to become an equity compensation specialist yourself. You need to be the advisor who read the award agreements and asked what the family could actually count on, and brought in specialized expertise to protect it.

Let's talk

Have a client who may benefit?

Bring the situation — we'll pressure‑test the fit and the structure together. New to working with Josh? Start with an Introduction.

And to be clear, this isn't a product pitch. Most of this planning is about reading the documents and sequencing decisions; insurance is one piece of it. If it's a fit, we'll build it together. If it's not, you'll walk away sharper.